We asked ChatGPT and Gemini about Park Slope dentists. They agreed on almost nothing.
In 30 seconds
- For whitening prices, ChatGPT named the practice that publishes them. Gemini named no practice at all.
- Gemini couldn’t give an address for two practices it recommended.
- For Delta Dental, Gemini gave one practice the same phone number ChatGPT gave a different one.
2AI assistants
20answers
36practices named
2questions with the same #1
What we found
In the AIs’ own words, from answers we got on October 19, 2026 (shortened).
Publish your prices and AI quotes you
Teeth whitening: how much does it cost?
ChatGPT
Named SMILELOUNGE: $300 express, $500 in-office, $750 with trays. “One publishes specific prices, which makes it a useful starting point.”
vs
Gemini
$300–$1,000. No practice named.
SMILELOUNGE publishes its whitening prices on its own site.
One AI had the address, the other said “call”
Gentle dentist for dental anxiety
ChatGPT
Advanced Gentle Dentistry of Park Slope, 443 9th St.
vs
Gemini
Advanced Gentle Dentistry: “Call for exact address.”
Gemini did the same for another practice it recommended for families.
Saturday near Grand Army Plaza: ChatGPT’s #1 never appeared on Gemini
Dentist near Grand Army Plaza open Saturday
ChatGPT
#1: Plaza Dental Arts, Sat 9–3, 5.0 (289 reviews).
vs
Gemini
#1: Dental365 Park Slope, Sat and Sun 9–3. Plaza Dental Arts not named.
Gemini wasn’t sure of Saturday hours for two of its other picks.
An insurance page on your own site gets you named
Dentist that takes Delta Dental
ChatGPT
#1: Park Slope Dentistry, which “lists Delta Dental PPO and Premier on its insurance page.”
vs
Gemini
#1: The Dental Spa of New York, “in-network Delta PPO.”
Only one practice, Tend, appeared on both lists.
Who each AI picked first
One dot per answer. Same color across a row means the assistants agreed.
| ChatGPT | Gemini | |
|---|---|---|
| Best dentist in Park Slope | ||
| Family dentist that sees kids | ||
| Emergency dentist, weekends both agree | ||
| Affordable dental implants | ||
| Invisalign | ||
| Takes Delta Dental | ||
| Gentle dentist for anxiety | ||
| Best pediatric dentist both agree | ||
| Teeth whitening cost | ||
| Near Grand Army Plaza, open Saturday |
Park Slope DentistryDental365 Park SlopeNoble Dental CareAdvanced Gentle DentistryBitesize Pediatric DentistryOtherNone named
See every #1 pick by name
| Question | ChatGPT | Gemini |
|---|---|---|
| Best dentist in Park Slope | Park Slope Dentistry | Five Dental |
| Family dentist that sees kids | Midtown Dental Group Park Slope | Noble Dental Care |
| Emergency dentist, weekends | Dental365 Park Slope | Dental365 Park Slope |
| Affordable dental implants | NYU Dentistry Brooklyn | Park Slope Dentistry |
| Invisalign | Park Slope Orthodontics | Park Dentistry |
| Takes Delta Dental | Park Slope Dentistry | The Dental Spa of New York |
| Gentle dentist for anxiety | Advanced Gentle Dentistry | Noble Dental Care |
| Best pediatric dentist | Bitesize Pediatric Dentistry | Bitesize Pediatric Dentistry |
| Teeth whitening cost | Advanced Gentle Dentistry | none named |
| Near Grand Army Plaza, open Saturday | Plaza Dental Arts | Dental365 Park Slope |
What a Park Slope practice can do this month
- Answer patients' questions on your site. Insurance by name, weekend hours, sedation, kids, nearby landmarks.
- Publish a starting price. "From $X" for whitening, implants and Invisalign.
- Same name, address, phone and hours everywhere. Your site, Google, Bing, Apple Maps, Yelp, Zocdoc, Healthgrades.
- Add Dentist schema. So assistants read your address, hours and services without guessing.
- Show up where AI looks. Local blogs, neighborhood guides, review sites, local Reddit threads.
- Test it every month. Ask ChatGPT and Gemini your patients' top 5 questions and note who gets named.
Is your practice in the answer?
We run your patients' real questions through ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode and Copilot and show you who gets named instead, and why.Free check: ChatGPT, 5 questions, same day. Full audit: 5 AIs, 20 questions, 48 hours.
Get my free check Full audit $79
