We asked five AI assistants about Murray Hill med spas. Not once did all five name the same business.
In 30 seconds
- One med spa’s Saturday hours were 10 to 6 on three AIs and 11 to 6 on two.
- For HydraFacial, the clinic with a dedicated HydraFacial page was #1 on three assistants.
- Google AI Mode gave one med spa 202 reviews in one answer and “more than 350” in another.
5AI assistants
50answers
59businesses named
10times one med spa was #1
What we found
In the AIs’ own words, from answers we got on October 21, 2026 (shortened).
Same med spa, two different Saturday hours
Med spa near Grand Central open on Saturday
ChatGPT
Perfect Med Spa: Saturday 10 AM – 6 PM.
vs
Gemini
Perfect Med Spa: Saturday 11 AM – 6 PM.
Perplexity and Google AI Mode said 10. Copilot said 11.
Same assistant, two different review counts
Where can I get microneedling in Murray Hill or Midtown East, Manhattan?
Google AI Mode
Perfect Med Spa: 4.8 (202 reviews).
vs
Med spa near Kips Bay or Murray Hill with good reviews
Google AI Mode
Perfect Med Spa: 4.8 (more than 350 reviews).
ChatGPT showed the same med spa at 4.3 with 39 reviews.
A dedicated page won HydraFacial; a published price won on Perplexity
Best place for a HydraFacial near Murray Hill, NYC
Copilot
#1: Murray Hill Plastic Surgery, “confirmed by its detailed HydraFacial page.”
vs
Perplexity
#1: Manhattan Medspa, “HydraFacial MD for $199.”
ChatGPT and Gemini also put the clinic with the HydraFacial page first.
“Affordable” lip filler: one AI showed prices, the other guessed
Affordable lip filler near Murray Hill, Manhattan
ChatGPT
#1: ELEVATE NYC: $300 half syringe, $500 full, from its booking page.
vs
Copilot
#1: Manhattan Aesthetics, “likely most affordable.” No price given.
Every one of ChatGPT’s picks had a published price or promotion.
Who each AI picked first
One dot per answer. Same color across a row means the assistants agreed.
| ChatGPT | Perplexity | Gemini | Copilot | AI Mode | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best med spa in Murray Hill | |||||
| Botox in Murray Hill | |||||
| Affordable lip filler | |||||
| Near Grand Central, open Saturday | |||||
| Laser hair removal cost | |||||
| Best HydraFacial | |||||
| Good for first-time Botox | |||||
| Microneedling | |||||
| Natural-looking Botox for men | |||||
| Good reviews, Kips Bay or Murray Hill |
Perfect Med SpaManhattan MedspaGrand Central MedspaDr. Roy SeidenbergManhattan AestheticsMurray Hill Plastic SurgeryOtherNone named
See every #1 pick by name
| Question | ChatGPT | Perplexity | Gemini | Copilot | Google AI Mode |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best med spa in Murray Hill | Diamond Advanced Aesthetics | Perfect Med Spa | Perfect Med Spa | Perfect Med Spa | Perfect Med Spa |
| Botox in Murray Hill | Dr. Roy Seidenberg | Manhattan Aesthetics | MDCS Dermatology | Dr. Roy Seidenberg | Perfect Med Spa |
| Affordable lip filler | ELEVATE NYC | Manhattan Medspa | Manhattan Medspa | Manhattan Aesthetics | Revival Med Spa |
| Near Grand Central, open Saturday | Grand Central Medspa | Grand Central Medspa | Grand Central Medspa | Skin Spa New York (Midtown) | Grand Central Medspa |
| Laser hair removal cost | Laser By Monica | BYou Laser Clinic | none named | none named | Perfect Med Spa |
| Best HydraFacial | Murray Hill Plastic Surgery | Manhattan Medspa | Murray Hill Plastic Surgery | Murray Hill Plastic Surgery | Perfect Med Spa |
| Good for first-time Botox | King Aesthetics | Manhattan Aesthetics | Manhattan Medspa | M Beauty Studio & Spa | Peachy Grand Central |
| Microneedling | Skin Lab Clinic | Aesthetically Pleasing Med Spa | Ease Spa Wellness | Skin City Lab | Perfect Med Spa |
| Natural-looking Botox for men | Dr. Roy Seidenberg | The Dermatology and Laser Group | King Aesthetics | James Christian Cosmetics | Lushful Aesthetics |
| Good reviews, Kips Bay or Murray Hill | King Aesthetics | Revival Med Spa | Perfect Med Spa | Manhattan Medspa | Perfect Med Spa |
What a Murray Hill med spa can do this month
- Give every main treatment its own page. Botox, filler, HydraFacial, microneedling, laser: what it is, who does it, how long it takes.
- Publish starting prices. On your site and your booking page (Fresha, Vagaro, Boulevard, Booksy). "From $X" is enough.
- Claim Bing Places. Copilot leans on it. It's free and takes about 15 minutes.
- Same hours and details everywhere. Google, Bing, Apple Maps, Yelp and your booking app should match your site exactly.
- Say where you are in plain words. "Murray Hill, three blocks from Grand Central", on your homepage and listings.
- Test it every month. Ask the five assistants your clients' top 5 questions and note who gets named.
Is your med spa in the answer?
We run your clients' real questions through ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode and Copilot and show you who gets named instead, and why.Free check: ChatGPT, 5 questions, same day. Full audit: 5 AIs, 20 questions, 48 hours.
Get my free check Full audit $79
